Roll-Off Dumpster Vs. Dump Trailer: The Complete Comparison

Construction, renovation, and home improvement jobs create a lot of trash. Replacing a roof, for example, involves tearing off the existing roofing material. A home renovation may include demolishing an existing wall or room. Roofers and builders typically rent a dumpster to haul away the trash at the end of a job, and they have two types of containers to choose from: a roll-off dumpster and a dump trailer.


What Are Roll-Off Dumpsters?

Typically, a Discount Dumpster Rental service will offer customers a range of roll-off dumpsters in different sizes. The smallest dumpsters are ideal for a small project, like cleaning out a garage, while the largest dumpsters are the right size for a roof replacement or a major renovation project.

The rental company delivers the dumpster to the worksite and hauls it away at the end of the rental period. A roll-off dumpster has small wheels which allow it to roll off the trailer and move into place.

What Are Dump Trailers?

A dump trailer is a trailer with an open top and walled sides, and it hitches to the back of another vehicle. In general, people who rent a dump trailer attach it to their own car or truck and haul the trash to the landfill themselves.

In addition, people who rent a dump trailer can easily move it from one site to another or to a different spot on the same property. Dump trailers are available in different frame types and sizes, ranging from 8 to 20 feet in length. They also have a hydraulic lift mechanism (like a dump truck) for dumping out the trash.

Comparing Roll-Off Dumpsters And Dump Trailers

Both types of waste containers have strengths, but the job and the user’s preferences will determine the best choice. The following is a comparison of dumpsters and dump trailers in terms of their capacity, cost, and convenience.


When it comes to hauling capacity, roll-off dumpsters have the advantage. For a full roof replacement, for example, a single 20-cubic-yard dumpster could hold all of the trash, while a large dump trailer would need to make two trips to the landfill.

In addition, dumpsters do a better job of holding large or long pieces of material. The sides of a dump trailer may not be high enough to fully contain large items.


The cost of renting a dumpster depends on several factors including the location, the size of the dumpster, and the weight of the trash. However, considering all of these factors, roll-off dumpsters tend to be less expensive to rent than dump trailers.

Not only do dump trailers cost more to rent per day, but customers also have to pay the landfill to dispose of the trash, and they have to use their own gas to transport the trailer.


Both dumpsters and dump trailers offer some conveniences. With a roll-off dumpster, the customer doesn’t have to worry about hauling the trash. With a dump trailer, the customer has more control of the placement. Dump trailers are a little easier to maneuver into tight spots, and their large wheels do less damage to landscaping than dumpster wheels.


Final Thoughts

Both roll-off dumpsters and dump trailers are effective solutions to the problem of cleaning up a work site or cleaning out a building. For small to medium-sized jobs, they work equally well. The largest jobs, however, will need a roll-off dumpster.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *